Watch: Survivor’s Brady Booker Slices Off Part of His Thumb With Machete
The tribe had not spoken for Rob Antonson.
The Survivor season 51 contestant voluntarily exited the game during the Oct. 7 episode after a failed attempt to vote for himself during Tribal Council, only to learn the move was against the rules.
“I thought everyone was voting Eric [Macksoud],” Antonson, 40, admitted in a confessional, referring to his fellow Rhode Island-based contestant. “I felt like if I could put my own name down, if he could play the Shot in the Dark or I can give him my Idol, all the ‘Erics’ would’ve canceled out and it would’ve just been my name.”
When he learned he couldn’t write down his own name, he instead voted for Macksoud—unaware that the rest of the Savu tribe had already set their sights on Ana Sani.
“I didn’t want to just quit,” Antonson said. “I feel like just quitting is just ruining the game.”
Simply put, “If you’re going out for a medical reason, that’s totally different.”
The following morning, Antonson told his tribemates he believed he may have injured himself while stepping into the ocean two days prior, causing an infection—a claim the other players said they doubted.
“You’ve been fine for the last 48 hours but the day things don’t go your way—now all of a sudden, it’s a medical issue,” tribemate Ori Jean-Charles said in a confessional. “My honest opinion is Rob is looking for an easy out.”
Robert Voets/CBS
A doctor from the show’s medical team arrived with host Jeff Probst to examine Antonson, but found no evidence of a “significant” injury beyond a small cut on the bottom of his foot.
After Probst confirmed there was no need to leave for medical reasons, Antonson said he didn’t want to risk a possible infection.
“If this is something that can be an infection or something, then yeah, I would take myself out of the game,” he explained. “I’m not gonna put my health at risk.”
Antonson, who found a Hidden Immunity Idol during the previous episode, had also shared that he missed his family and was struggling to sleep on the island—factors that may have led to his attempt to vote himself out in what he described would be a “groundbreaking” move.
“We always tell players the rules of the game,” Probst wrote in notes shared by the Survivor Instagram account, “which are very few but do include: ‘you cannot vote for yourself.’”
That rule firmly etched in stone—and on the ‘gram—just one that keeps the Survivor castaways on their toes. Keep reading for more secrets and insights from the long-running competition series.
Robert Voets/CBS via Getty Images
CBS via Getty Images
CBS via Getty Images
Monty Brinton/CBS via Getty Images
Timothy Kuratek/CBS via Getty Images
CBS Photo Archive / Contributor / GETTY IMAGES
Monty Brinton/CBS via Getty Images
Monty Brinton/CBS via Getty Images
CBS Photo Archive / Contributor / GETTY IMAGES
Eric Charbonneau/Invision/AP
Robert Voets/CBS via Getty Images
Monty Brinton/CBS Photo Archive via Getty Images
For the latest breaking news updates, click here to download the E! News App






