Watch: ‘The Challenge’ Winner Tyler Duckworth Dead at 44
The death of Tyler Duckworth sent a jolt through the bonded-forever family of contestants who aced The Challenge.
“Absolutely heartbroken to hear about Tyler,” Brad Fiorenza—who teamed with his then-wife Toni Hall, Duckworth and Dunbar Merrill to win the MTV competition’s 20th season, The Challenge: Cutthroat, in 2010—posted on Instagram Aug. 13. “We shared something special being part of The Challenge family. I’ll always be grateful for the memories we shared…Tyler will be deeply missed by so many. May his amazing soul live on in the lives he’s touched.”
In paying tribute, Fiorenza shared a photo of himself with Duckworth and fellow alums Mark Long, Rachel Robinson, Tina Barta and Paulie Calafiore from a recent Challenge Mania podcast event. Duckworth shared the same pic Aug. 2, his final Instagram post.
The 44-year-old’s mother, Joni Duckworth, shared on Facebook Aug. 13 that her son died “earlier this week,” and the cause wasn’t yet known. The Grand Forks Police Department told E! News that Duckworth was found dead in a bathroom of his North Dakota home after they were called to do a welfare check.
Johnny “Bananas” Devenanzio—who appeared on The Real World: Key West with Duckworth in 2006 and teamed with him to win 2011’s The Challenge: Rivals—wrote on X, “When it rains it pours” with a heartbreak emoji.
Calafiore replied to the post, “Legends never die.”
Tyler Duckworth/Instagram
Devenanzio—who’s competing on the show’s currently unfolding 42nd season, also dubbed The Challenge: Cutthroats—said recently that “this sense of mortality has crept in” that he didn’t think about when he was younger.
“It’s like, throw myself off a building, jump in front of a semi-truck, go on spring break for six weeks, and none of that used to have any effect on me,” the 44-year-old told People in an interview published Aug. 13. “Now I show up, and I have to set my schedule like, “Okay, what days can I work out so I’m not sore if there’s a challenge coming up?'”
But even though the 25-time Challenge contestant says he hesitates “every single time” he’s asked to come back, it remains “a really fun ride.”
MTV/Paramount+
One that has taken on a whole new meaning this season in the wake of Duckworth’s death.
“I thought they lost my number because I won two Challenges in a row and then never heard from them again,” Duckworth, who taught middle school and high school after his first reality TV run, told Entertainment Weekly in 2021 when he returned for The Challenge: All Stars 2. “It felt like I was being punished for doing so well. I love the opportunity to jump off buildings, to bungee jump, to eat crazy things—so absolutely. Sign me up for whatever. I’m down for all of it.”
Read on to remember more MTV show alums, including stars of The Challenge who have died since the series premiered in 1998:
Tyler Duckworth/Instagram
Carley Margolis/FilmMagic
David Becker/Getty Images for SHOWTIME SPORTS
Gustavo Caballero/Getty Images for The Miami Project
Michael Loccisano/FilmMagic
Mike Coppola/Getty Images
Jason Merritt/FilmMagic
Mike Coppola/Getty Images
Sussman/Invision/AP Images
Brian To/Getty Images For Beverly Center
Raymond Boyd/Michael Ochs Archives/Getty Image






